Pacifying Resistance

Download Video
Transcribe / Translate

Some of the most celebrated social justice victories of the 20th century are attributed to the great pacifists of our time, Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King. This constitutes a historical whitewash, as these “victories” were achieved when the state weighed its options and chose the lesser of two evils: the pacifists. In this segment Derrick Jensen, Lierre Keith, Aric Mcbay, Harjap Grewal, Gord Hill and Peter Gelderloos deconstruct the Gandhi myth and show us why militant action plays an important role in movements of resistance.

Music by stig inge oy. and CJ Boyd

    This entry was posted on Sunday, August 1, 2010 at 10:13 am and is poested under OTHER SHIT category.

    6 Responses to “Pacifying Resistance”

  • LoLo says:

    well behaved women rarely go down in history.

  • mavaddat says:

    This video is like a Las Vegas buffet of confusions…

    It lumps together all forms of direct-action activism in the same serving container (mixing up nonsensical acts of vandalism with ethically legitimate armed-resistance) and labels it “militancy.”

    Then, it mixes up persuading reasonable people to join ranks in opposing the status quo (which is what reformists are really advocating) with a straw man salad of persuading corporations directly.

    Last, it demands you only choose between a plate of this “militancy” melange or else a bowl of pathetic “pacifism” (with a side of “persuading sociopaths”).

    The reality is that many forms of “militancy” are totally morally unjustified (amounting to nothing more than an attempt o relieve frustration in a symbolic act of destruction) and actually do grave harm to our cause (including their own), thereby resulting in lost public support (yes, eventually winning the support of the masses really does matter).

    Malcolm X and the Nation of Islam advocated violent resistance when necessary to protect human rights, which was absolutely warranted (ethically). They never endorsed “symbolic acts of vandalism,” which is what this generation has understood “militant activism” to mean. We no longer understand warranted, effective forms of militancy. We don’t care if it works, or if it furthers our goals. We just want an outlet for our anger, our angst. But such equivocations between do nothing to show us the way.

    Instead, it remains self-deception to suggest that “breaking shit” amounts to anything remotely approaching an actual threat to the state or to capitalism. It does not.

  • stimulator says:

    @mavaddat thanks for your comment.

    You seem to have a bone to pick with those who choose black bloc tactics. Fair enough. But this video is not about measuring the efficacy of different types of militant actions. And yes, black bloc is militant, weather you agree with it that’s a different story.

    But by the looks of it, you don’t oppose militant action which is why your analysis is so nuanced. This video is not meant to promote one type of action or another, or to simply dispel non-violent resistance. The video is meant to show how militant actions put pressure on the rulers and how history has cleaned the record of these.

  • Rottin Roti says:

    This is gonna be a mammoth fucking project when its done, are you planning on touring with it? If so, make sure you come back to Toronto. It probably sucked being here during the G20 but I know a lot of people that would love to see a film like this.

  • […] If you like this you might also want to check out “The Resistance is Blowing up!” and “Pacifying Resistance“ […]

  • Leave a Reply

    block-everything

    BLOCK EVERYTHING

    This week we catch up on the multi-layered insurrection taking place in France, where the state is struggling to get a handle on things, amidst regular protests, strikes, fuel shortages,...

    crisis-of-democracy

    THE CRISIS OF DEMOCRACY

      This week we look at the current turmoil in South America, where the so-called “pink tide” is beginning to recede in Venezuela and Brazil as the United Snakes seeks...

    Protesting migrants try to bring down part of a border fence as Macedonian police stand guard during clashes at a makeshift camp for refugees and migrants at the Greek-Macedonian border near the village of Idomeni, Greece, April 10, 2016. REUTERS/Alexandros Avramidis

    Smashing the Fortress

      This week, we take a look at the tens of thousands of migrants tapped in limbo in Europe, facing down the prospect of being deported back to the war...

    booty1

    Stashing the Booty

    This week we take you inside the sketchy world of booty hiding, otherwise known as offshore tax havens. If you love what we do, consider supporting us! In the music...

    Paris is Burning

    Paris is Burning!

    This week we take a look at the multiple converging flashpoints of resistance in France, which have combined into a popular movement that has inspired over a million peeps to...

    stim_heart_bernie

    Stim <3 Bernie

    After much reflection, I have decided to throw my support behind Bernie Sanders. This short video explains why. Related After much reflection, I have decided to throw my support behind...

    • Donate with

      Donate with BitCoin

    • or PayPal

      • 70% funded
      • $1058 cleared
      • $2 pending
      • $1060 / $1500 total
    • @stimulator